Difference between Porsche and VW 1700 engine
-
- Posts: 46
- Joined: Tue Jan 17, 2006 11:14 pm
Difference between Porsche and VW 1700 engine
Hi everybody, this question has probably been asked before but I couldn't find an answer using the search function.
I've been offered to buy a W code 1700 Porsche engine and I am wondering if it is any different from a standard VW 1700 engine, I've found out that the pistons are different but thats it... I need to know more.
Apparently the 2L Porsche engine had good heads that could be fitted to the 1700 using the 1800 barrels and pistons, but would it still be a good buy if I chose to stick with the stock heads? I don't really need another engine right now but I wouldn't like to miss out on a bargain if the Porsche 1700 turns out to be a rare type4 machine very different from the VW 1700.
I've been offered to buy a W code 1700 Porsche engine and I am wondering if it is any different from a standard VW 1700 engine, I've found out that the pistons are different but thats it... I need to know more.
Apparently the 2L Porsche engine had good heads that could be fitted to the 1700 using the 1800 barrels and pistons, but would it still be a good buy if I chose to stick with the stock heads? I don't really need another engine right now but I wouldn't like to miss out on a bargain if the Porsche 1700 turns out to be a rare type4 machine very different from the VW 1700.
- slowtwitch
- Posts: 533
- Joined: Mon Nov 08, 2004 9:38 am
- Cohibra45
- Posts: 295
- Joined: Sun Jan 30, 2005 7:50 pm
I think that both Porsche and VW used the same engine for different cars. I'm sure that Jake or Dave Darling, Tuna or Bleysing will know if there are differences in cams/heads/pistons, ect...But according to Tunas research/reference page: http://www.tunacan.net/t4/reference/case.htm
the case is the same used for the 411 and 914.
I don't think it is a 'super scarce' Porsche or anything, but I could be wrong.
Take care,
Kelly (Cohibra45)
the case is the same used for the 411 and 914.
I don't think it is a 'super scarce' Porsche or anything, but I could be wrong.
Take care,
Kelly (Cohibra45)
-
- Posts: 426
- Joined: Sun Aug 05, 2007 4:31 pm
- raygreenwood
- Posts: 11895
- Joined: Wed Jan 22, 2003 12:01 am
- Cohibra45
- Posts: 295
- Joined: Sun Jan 30, 2005 7:50 pm
-
- Posts: 426
- Joined: Sun Aug 05, 2007 4:31 pm
- MNAirHead
- Posts: 9570
- Joined: Mon Sep 08, 2003 6:12 am
When you say different spec.. do you mean compression?raygreenwood wrote:There is absolutely no difference whatsoever between the 411/412 1.7 engine and the 914 1.7 engine. ther are minor details like oil filler and dipstick. The same down to the last part# and spec.
The bus 1.7 engine is totally differnt in spec but all the same castings. Ray
- tuna
- Posts: 2531
- Joined: Fri Apr 14, 2000 12:01 am
The 1700 was used in three cars: 914, 411/412, and Bus. They are almost identical.
The 914 and the 411/412 sedan used one style of shroud, oil filler, and oil dipstick. The oil filler was bolted to the breather box, the shroud had a threaded hole to access the timing marks, and the dipstick was in the case next to the breather tower.
The Bus and the 411/412 used the other style. The oil filler is bolted towards the bottom of the case. The oil dipstick goes through the shroud and enters through the oil filler. The fan shroud doesn't have a threaded access port for timing.
There are a few differences, mostly camshaft timing (auto vs. manual, intended fuel, etc.) and the compression ratio. As far as I know, there isn't any definitive way of identifying where the engine came from, besides analyzing the engine and checking the pistons.
As for the windage tray, I've yet to figure out what they came on and when. I've seen 411/412 engines with it, some without. The same goes for 914 and Bus engines.
Tuna
The 914 and the 411/412 sedan used one style of shroud, oil filler, and oil dipstick. The oil filler was bolted to the breather box, the shroud had a threaded hole to access the timing marks, and the dipstick was in the case next to the breather tower.
The Bus and the 411/412 used the other style. The oil filler is bolted towards the bottom of the case. The oil dipstick goes through the shroud and enters through the oil filler. The fan shroud doesn't have a threaded access port for timing.
There are a few differences, mostly camshaft timing (auto vs. manual, intended fuel, etc.) and the compression ratio. As far as I know, there isn't any definitive way of identifying where the engine came from, besides analyzing the engine and checking the pistons.
As for the windage tray, I've yet to figure out what they came on and when. I've seen 411/412 engines with it, some without. The same goes for 914 and Bus engines.
Tuna
http://vdubgeek.blogspot.com/
Type 4: Secrets Revealed - https://type4secrets.blogspot.com/
Tom's Type 4 Corner - coming soon!
EMPI Imp Homepage - coming soon!
My VWs - http://vdubgeek.blogspot.com/p/my-vdubs_5.html
Type 4: Secrets Revealed - https://type4secrets.blogspot.com/
Tom's Type 4 Corner - coming soon!
EMPI Imp Homepage - coming soon!
My VWs - http://vdubgeek.blogspot.com/p/my-vdubs_5.html
-
- Posts: 20132
- Joined: Fri Jul 07, 2000 12:01 am
-
- Posts: 2830
- Joined: Wed May 30, 2001 12:01 am
As for windage trays, when I was into 914's some 1700's had them and some did not???? After I build my first 914 I found out some had windage trays. I was upset because I thought it was a great idea especially on a 914 which took hard turns, but I was not about to split the case just to put one in.
I have no clue why some had them and some did not???
I have no clue why some had them and some did not???
Joe Cali
The Type IV Upright Conversion Manual
Beetle Magnetic Deflector Shield
http://www.nextgen-usa.com
Next Generation-U.S.A.
Email: [email protected]
or
[email protected]
The Type IV Upright Conversion Manual
Beetle Magnetic Deflector Shield
http://www.nextgen-usa.com
Next Generation-U.S.A.
Email: [email protected]
or
[email protected]
- raygreenwood
- Posts: 11895
- Joined: Wed Jan 22, 2003 12:01 am
I have never seen any of my personnal 411/412's without a windage tray in the engine. These models ranged from August of 72, Nov 73, Jan of 72, sept 74....off the top of my head.
Aside from some of the very small detail differences in the cases that Jake and Tuna are alluding to that have to do with various casting runs and part #'s......the 1.7L as it came in the 411/412/914...were all the same in spec.
Wether they were aut or manual they had 8.2:1 compression with domed pistons and all came with D-jet. Because of this ...save for the early 411's (68-early 71) that only made it to the USA as gray market.....all of the 411/412/914 1.7's used the same cam with the same valve timing, even in the Auto's. Ray
Aside from some of the very small detail differences in the cases that Jake and Tuna are alluding to that have to do with various casting runs and part #'s......the 1.7L as it came in the 411/412/914...were all the same in spec.
Wether they were aut or manual they had 8.2:1 compression with domed pistons and all came with D-jet. Because of this ...save for the early 411's (68-early 71) that only made it to the USA as gray market.....all of the 411/412/914 1.7's used the same cam with the same valve timing, even in the Auto's. Ray